Fire Island vs Carmel, NY

Fire Island currently scores 2 points higher overall than Carmel, with the largest gap in storm surge.

Use this comparison for relocation decisions, insurance shopping, and hazard-prioritized mitigation planning.

Fire Island

37/100

Carmel

35/100

Hazard breakdown

Overall

Fire Island: 37/100 · Carmel: 35/100

Fire Island is 2 points higher.

Flood

Fire Island: 69/100 · Carmel: 41/100

Fire Island is 28 points higher.

Wind

Fire Island: 36/100 · Carmel: 22/100

Fire Island is 14 points higher.

Lightning

Fire Island: 14/100 · Carmel: 20/100

Carmel is 6 points higher.

Tornado

Fire Island: 0/100 · Carmel: 31/100

Carmel is 31 points higher.

Hail

Fire Island: 3/100 · Carmel: 30/100

Carmel is 27 points higher.

Storm surge

Fire Island: 96/100 · Carmel: 0/100

Fire Island is 96 points higher.

Compare with another city