← Back to Fire Island snapshotCity comparison page
City vs city
Fire Island vs New York, NY
New York currently scores 14 points higher overall than Fire Island, with the largest gap in hail.
Use this comparison for relocation decisions, insurance shopping, and hazard-prioritized mitigation planning.
Hazard breakdown
Overall
Fire Island: 35/100 · New York: 49/100
New York is 14 points higher.
Flood
Fire Island: 69/100 · New York: 50/100
Fire Island is 19 points higher.
Wind
Fire Island: 36/100 · New York: 24/100
Fire Island is 12 points higher.
Lightning
Fire Island: 14/100 · New York: 19/100
New York is 5 points higher.
Tornado
Fire Island: 0/100 · New York: 0/100
No gap.
Hail
Fire Island: 3/100 · New York: 55/100
New York is 52 points higher.
Storm surge
Fire Island: 96/100 · New York: 99/100
New York is 3 points higher.