← Back to Smithville Flats snapshotCity comparison page
City vs city
Smithville Flats vs Carmel, NY
Carmel currently scores 13 points higher overall than Smithville Flats, with the largest gap in tornado.
Use this comparison for relocation decisions, insurance shopping, and hazard-prioritized mitigation planning.
Hazard breakdown
Overall
Smithville Flats: 21/100 · Carmel: 34/100
Carmel is 13 points higher.
Flood
Smithville Flats: 17/100 · Carmel: 41/100
Carmel is 24 points higher.
Wind
Smithville Flats: 18/100 · Carmel: 22/100
Carmel is 4 points higher.
Lightning
Smithville Flats: 17/100 · Carmel: 20/100
Carmel is 3 points higher.
Tornado
Smithville Flats: 4/100 · Carmel: 32/100
Carmel is 28 points higher.
Hail
Smithville Flats: 21/100 · Carmel: 31/100
Carmel is 10 points higher.
Storm surge
Smithville Flats: 0/100 · Carmel: 0/100
No gap.