Fishers Island vs Carmel, NY

Carmel currently scores 12 points higher overall than Fishers Island, with the largest gap in storm surge.

Use this comparison for relocation decisions, insurance shopping, and hazard-prioritized mitigation planning.

Fishers Island

22/100

Carmel

34/100

Hazard breakdown

Overall

Fishers Island: 22/100 · Carmel: 34/100

Carmel is 12 points higher.

Flood

Fishers Island: 0/100 · Carmel: 41/100

Carmel is 41 points higher.

Wind

Fishers Island: 36/100 · Carmel: 22/100

Fishers Island is 14 points higher.

Lightning

Fishers Island: 10/100 · Carmel: 20/100

Carmel is 10 points higher.

Tornado

Fishers Island: 8/100 · Carmel: 32/100

Carmel is 24 points higher.

Hail

Fishers Island: 4/100 · Carmel: 31/100

Carmel is 27 points higher.

Storm surge

Fishers Island: 96/100 · Carmel: 0/100

Fishers Island is 96 points higher.

Compare with another city