← Back to Carthage snapshotCity comparison page
City vs city
Carthage vs Saint Clair, MO
Carthage currently scores 8 points higher overall than Saint Clair, with the largest gap in lightning.
Use this comparison for relocation decisions, insurance shopping, and hazard-prioritized mitigation planning.
Hazard breakdown
Overall
Carthage: 49/100 · Saint Clair: 41/100
Carthage is 8 points higher.
Flood
Carthage: 52/100 · Saint Clair: 51/100
Carthage is 1 points higher.
Wind
Carthage: 17/100 · Saint Clair: 16/100
Carthage is 1 points higher.
Lightning
Carthage: 79/100 · Saint Clair: 52/100
Carthage is 27 points higher.
Tornado
Carthage: 8/100 · Saint Clair: 12/100
Saint Clair is 4 points higher.
Hail
Carthage: 100/100 · Saint Clair: 86/100
Carthage is 14 points higher.
Storm surge
Carthage: 0/100 · Saint Clair: 0/100
No gap.