City vs city
Butler Beach vs St. Augustine, FL
Butler Beach currently scores 3 points higher overall than St. Augustine, with the largest gap in wildfire.
Use this comparison for relocation decisions, insurance shopping, and hazard-prioritized mitigation planning.
Hazard breakdown
Scores describe each city’s reference grid tile, not every property. A missing model is unavailable, not zero risk. Air quality uses an ingested EPA AirNow snapshot and may not reflect current conditions; other factors describe baseline exposure. The overall score blends different hazards and is not a probability of damage. Read the scoring methodology and sources.
Overall
Butler Beach: 44/100 · St. Augustine: 41/100
Butler Beach is 3 points higher.
Flood
Butler Beach: 36/100 · St. Augustine: 48/100
St. Augustine is 12 points higher.
Butler Beach: FEMA NFHL flood zones: 14 features intersect this tile.
St. Augustine: FEMA NFHL flood zones: 23 features intersect this tile.
Wind
Butler Beach: 38/100 · St. Augustine: 35/100
Butler Beach is 3 points higher.
Butler Beach: Wind exposure derived from ingested design wind / climatology tiles.
St. Augustine: Wind exposure derived from ingested design wind / climatology tiles.
Lightning
Butler Beach: 87/100 · St. Augustine: 93/100
St. Augustine is 6 points higher.
Butler Beach: Lightning exposure derived from ingested climatology tiles.
St. Augustine: Lightning exposure derived from ingested climatology tiles.
Tornado
Butler Beach: 46/100 · St. Augustine: 15/100
Butler Beach is 31 points higher.
Butler Beach: Tornado risk derived from NOAA SPC historical reports.
St. Augustine: Tornado risk derived from NOAA SPC historical reports.
Hail
Butler Beach: 20/100 · St. Augustine: 14/100
Butler Beach is 6 points higher.
Butler Beach: Hail risk derived from NOAA SPC historical reports.
St. Augustine: Hail risk derived from NOAA SPC historical reports.
Storm surge
Butler Beach: 98/100 · St. Augustine: Unavailable
A score difference cannot be calculated without both sources.
Butler Beach: Storm surge exposure derived from NOAA SLOSH MOM (AGL) data.
St. Augustine: Storm surge model is not available for this location yet.
Wildfire
Butler Beach: 12/100 · St. Augustine: 64/100
St. Augustine is 52 points higher.
Butler Beach: Wildfire exposure derived from ingested fire potential tiles.
St. Augustine: Wildfire exposure derived from ingested fire potential tiles.
Ingested air quality
Butler Beach: 17/100 · St. Augustine: 18/100
St. Augustine is 1 points higher.
Butler Beach: Air quality score derived from the latest ingested EPA AirNow AQI grid; may not reflect current conditions. See methodology for the recorded ingest date.
St. Augustine: Air quality score derived from the latest ingested EPA AirNow AQI grid; may not reflect current conditions. See methodology for the recorded ingest date.