City vs city
Butler Beach vs St. Augustine, FL
St. Augustine currently scores 8 points higher overall than Butler Beach, with the largest gap in hail.
Use this comparison for relocation decisions, insurance shopping, and hazard-prioritized mitigation planning.
Hazard breakdown
Overall
Butler Beach: 45/100 · St. Augustine: 53/100
St. Augustine is 8 points higher.
Flood
Butler Beach: 36/100 · St. Augustine: 41/100
St. Augustine is 5 points higher.
Wind
Butler Beach: 38/100 · St. Augustine: 37/100
Butler Beach is 1 points higher.
Lightning
Butler Beach: 87/100 · St. Augustine: 90/100
St. Augustine is 3 points higher.
Tornado
Butler Beach: 48/100 · St. Augustine: 20/100
Butler Beach is 28 points higher.
Hail
Butler Beach: 21/100 · St. Augustine: 65/100
St. Augustine is 44 points higher.
Storm surge
Butler Beach: 98/100 · St. Augustine: 97/100
Butler Beach is 1 points higher.